A government report confirms a large crop, yet grain futures rise. Another report delivers seemingly strong news about demand, yet prices fall.
These are hypothetical examples. But they illustrate an important concept. Agricultural markets react not to the news itself, but to how the news compares with expectations.
If traders anticipate a monster crop and a government report shows a crop that’s still large but smaller than expected, futures may rise. The news was less negative than anticipated. Conversely, a demand report may show positive data, but if traders were penciling in even stronger demand, futures could fall.
Futures markets are driven by the gap between expectations and reality. This matters more than whether the news, taken at face value, appears positive or negative.
What was priced in?
You’ll often hear that something is “priced in.” This means it has already been anticipated and incorporated into prices.
Every day, a market digests the latest news about weather forecasts, exports, crop conditions, government reports and geopolitics. Collectively, this helps form an expectation for where prices are headed.
New pieces of data can change perceptions.
Consider a hypothetical Canadian canola production report. Analysts expect 20 million tonnes, but Statistics Canada estimates 19.5 million tonnes. That is still a substantial crop. Nevertheless, canola futures could move higher. The estimate was smaller than the market had anticipated.
The reverse can happen. Seemingly positive news can disappoint, leading to selling. For example, large export sales may not lift prices if traders had expected them to be even larger.
This happens frequently. And it’s been happening for decades. In 2026, corn futures plunged in early October after the USDA reported a larger-than-expected U.S. crop. But The Western Producer also documented times when canola rose despite an increased crop estimate, because supportive signals from other oilseeds outweighed the negative effect of the crop data.
From my experience
One of the mistakes I have made in market analysis is confusing the news with the direction prices should move. Being right about a large crop, weak demand or threatening weather does not necessarily mean being right about the next step for prices. Those things may already be reflected in prices.
Markets do not reward you simply for knowing something. What matters is recognizing what has changed relative to what was expected. Master this concept and you’ll find you’re much better at understanding why markets move the way that they do.
This article is part of a series from The Western Producer and Farmtario Markets Desks exploring the forces that move agricultural markets and influence the decisions that shape farm marketing. An earlier video on the importance of the basis can be found here.














