Carbon-Related Tariffs and Energy Policy

Climate change is a big concern for everyone. Many countries want to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and reach tough climate goals, and one growing idea is the carbon-related tariff. 

These tariffs target goods that produce high carbon emissions. By adding extra costs for carbon-heavy imports, policymakers hope to push industries worldwide to adopt cleaner methods. 

Below, we’ll break down carbon-related tariffs and energy policy in simpler terms. We’ll look at how they work, which places are leading, how they affect various industries and nations, and the challenges they present. 

What Are Carbon-Related Tariffs? 

Carbon-related tariffs place fees on imported goods based on how much carbon dioxide (CO2) the production process rates. 

The idea is simple: If one region has strict climate rules and charges local businesses fees for their carbon emissions, those businesses could lose their edge if foreign competitors face no such costs. When imports don’t bear the same carbon-associated fees, local firms may struggle to compete on price. 

Carbon tariffs can help solve this by adding an import fee (or tariff) that reflects the imported product’s associated greenhouse gas emissions. This ensures that local and foreign producers face similar costs, leveling the playing field. Such tariffs also aim to prevent carbon leakage, which is when companies move production to places with weaker emissions rules. 

In international trade, carbon tariffs raise questions about whether they fit the World Trade Organization (WTO) rules. Supporters say these tariffs are fair if applied evenly and tied to actual emissions levels. Critics worry they could become a protectionist tool. 

How Do Carbon Tariffs Affect Industries Reliant on Fossil Fuels?

Industries like steel and cement use large amounts of fossil fuel in their processes. These sectors typically have a high emissions intensity, producing a lot of carbon dioxide per unit of output. Because of this, carbon tariffs can significantly impact them. 

If a region with strict climate rules places a carbon tariff on goods like steel, foreign companies must either reduce emissions or pay extra fees. This levels the field for local firms that already pay a domestic carbon price through a cap-and-trade or carbon tax system. Many domestic steel and cement producers see carbon tariffs as a way to protect them from cheaper, higher-emission imports. 

On the other hand, these tariffs can raise costs for industries that rely on global supply chains. If iron ore or other raw materials come from places without carbon taxes, finished products might face extra fees. This might push manufacturers to switch to suppliers with lower CO2 emissions. Over time, the steel and cement sectors may invest in clean technologies, like carbon capture or hydrogen-based methods, to avoid these extra costs. 

How Do Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanisms (CBAMs) Impact Global Energy Markets? 

A carbon border adjustment mechanism (CBAM) is one kind of carbon-related tariff. When a region — the European Union, for example — adopts a CBAM, it imposes a carbon charge on imports that matches what local producers pay under that region’s own emissions trading system or carbon tax. The goal is to keep costs fair for local businesses while nudging foreign companies to reduce their CO2 emissions. 

These changes can have far-reaching effects on global energy markets. For instance, nations that rely on fossil fuel exports, such as Russia, could see a drop in demand if buyers have to pay extra for goods with a high emissions intensity. Meanwhile, major manufacturing hubs like China might upgrade factories to lower emissions to avoid additional costs. 

A CBAM can also help shift energy policy, encouraging more renewable energy and less reliance on coal or natural gas. Over time, the global energy mix may evolve and focus more on clean sources. These mechanisms can also push governments to think more about trade policy and whether new trade agreements should address carbon costs, especially when partnering with regions that already have or are planning to adopt a CBAM. 

The Economic and Political Challenges of Enforcing Carbon-Related Tariffs

Enforcing carbon tariffs can be tricky. One challenge is calculating the carbon emissions involved in making each product. Many goods pass through complex supply chains with parts made in different countries. Data on inputs and energy use can be unreliable, so deciding the correct tariff amount can become a guessing game. 

Carbon tariffs can cause political tension between trading partners. Some nations view them as fair steps toward lowering global emissions, while others see them as sanctions that harm their businesses. For instance, developing countries might argue that they do not have the same resources to meet tough climate standards and worry that carbon tariffs will block their exports. 

Politics also matter within a country. Policy can shift when leadership changes. This back-and-forth makes long-term planning hard for businesses. Countries that dislike carbon tariffs might retaliate with their own measures, leading to trade disputes and more complexity in the World Trade Organization (WTO).  

Learn how to calculate your carbon footprint here. 

What Impact Do Carbon-Related Tariffs Have on Developing Nations and Their Energy Policies? 

Developing countries often depend on high-emission industries and cheaper energy sources like coal. They might lack funding to shift to cleaner fuels quickly. When they face carbon tariffs, their goods might become pricier, reducing their competitiveness in foreign markets. 

This pressure may push them to reform their energy policy, adopt more renewable sources, or use cleaner fuels like natural gas. However, such transitions require investment in new infrastructure and technology, which can be difficult for nations with smaller budgets. Fortunately, part of the revenue from carbon tariffs could be given to poorer nations to help them invest in clean technologies, bridging the gap and ensuring they are not unfairly penalized. 

On the political side, developing nations sometimes consider carbon tariffs an extra burden. They could argue that rich countries built their economies through carbon-heavy industries before restrictions existed, so the new limits shouldn’t restrict poorer countries’ growth. A phased approach or carbon tariff exemptions may be helpful options for nations that are still building basic industrial capacity and lack many emissions-reducing options. 

How Do Businesses and Supply Chains Adapt to the Introduction of Carbon Tariffs? 

Once carbon tariffs are enacted, companies must learn about the emissions tied to their entire supply chain. They may need to ask themselves several questions, such as: 

• Where do our materials come from? 
• Which factories make them, and what is their carbon-intensive level? 

If a supplier has high CO2 emissions, the final product could be more expensive once the import fees are added. To address this, businesses often look for ways to reduce their carbon footprint. They might adopt clean technologies, like switching to renewable electricity or adding carbon capture. They may also shift to suppliers in regions with greener power grids. By doing so, they reduce the chance of facing extra charges at the border. 

Another approach is to relocate parts of the supply chain. For instance, a firm might move specific manufacturing steps to countries with a domestic carbon price already in place or places with cheaper wind energy or solar power access. Over time, industries that respond well may reap benefits as global markets favor goods with lower emissions. 

What Role Do Carbon-Related Tariffs Play In Promoting Clean Energy Investments? 

Carbon-related tariffs raise costs for goods with high greenhouse gas emissions. By adding fees to carbon-heavy products, they push companies to invest in cleaner methods and avoid extra charges. For example, a steel firm might switch to hydrogen-based steelmaking to cut emissions and reduce border fees. 

Governments can use tariff revenue to support renewable energy or advance cleaner technology. This gives businesses reasons to move away from high-carbon processes. The money can fund solar or wind power incentives or pay for training workers in new green skills. 

When major markets like the European Union adopt CBAMs, it sparks change worldwide. Companies aiming to sell there must adopt cleaner practices, fueling a wave of innovation. Over time, this helps lower global emissions and moves the world closer to key climate goals. 

Carbon-Related Tariffs Can Force the World to Become Greener Over Time

Carbon-related tariffs and energy policy are closely linked as governments look for ways to address climate change while protecting local industries. By charging imports for the carbon emissions tied to their production, these tariffs aim to prevent carbon leakage and ensure that goods from abroad follow rules similar to those at home. Theoretically, this encourages cleaner production across global supply chains and motivates countries to set more ambitious climate goals. 

However, these tariffs are not without challenges. Measuring emissions can be complex, and policies must align with WTO standards to avoid legal disputes. Developing countries often need extra resources or time to comply, so they do not feel unfairly targeted by wealthy nations that had decades of carbon-heavy growth. To remain competitive, businesses might have to revamp supply chains, invest in clean technologies, or shift production to greener regions. 

Carbon tariffs are one way to help with global climate change, but you can also do so by finding an electricity provider with a high mix of green energy or one offering 100% green energy.  

Compare residential electricity plans and pricing at Just Energy, including plans with JustGreen.

Brought to you by justenergy.com

All images licensed from Adobe Stock.

The post Carbon-Related Tariffs and Energy Policy appeared first on Just Energy.

• Source: https://justenergy.com/blog/carbon-related-tariffs-and-energy-policy/