Which Thanksgiving Pie Is Uniquely Popular in Your State?

Like
Liked

Date:

Which Thanksgiving Pies Are Especially Popular in Your State?

Key Takeaways

  • Pumpkin pie dominates much of the West, while sweet potato and pecan pies are regional favorites in the South.
  • Cream pie is uniquely popular in nine states, more than any other variety.
  • Apple pie is America’s second-most-ordered Thanksgiving pie, yet doesn’t appear as the uniquely popular choice in any state.

Pumpkin pie might be the classic Thanksgiving dessert, but Americans have plenty of other favorites. From peanut butter pie in parts of the South to French silk pie across the Midwest, this map reveals which varieties are especially popular in each state compared with the national average.

The visualization is based on Instacart’s analysis of grocery orders from November 22–28, 2024, published in 2025.

America’s Most Uniquely Popular Thanksgiving Pies by State

The table below shows which pie is uniquely popular in each state and Washington, D.C., based on Instacart orders during Thanksgiving week in 2024.

These aren’t necessarily each state’s best-selling pies. Instead, Instacart identifies varieties purchased at unusually high rates compared with their share of orders nationwide.

State / district Most uniquely popular pie
Alabama French silk pie
Alaska Pumpkin pie
Arizona Cherry pie
Arkansas Peanut butter pie
California Pumpkin pie
Colorado Cherry pie
Connecticut Strawberry rhubarb pie
Delaware Coconut custard pie
District of Columbia Sweet potato pie
Florida Peanut butter pie
Georgia Sweet potato pie
Hawaii Cream pie
Idaho Pumpkin pie
Illinois French silk pie
Indiana Cream pie
Iowa French silk pie
Kansas French silk pie
Kentucky Chocolate pie
Louisiana Peanut butter pie
Maine Cream pie
Maryland Sweet potato pie
Massachusetts Cream pie
Michigan Sweet potato pie
Minnesota French silk pie
Mississippi Pecan pie
Missouri French silk pie
Montana Cream pie
Nebraska French silk pie
Nevada Pumpkin pie
New Hampshire Cream pie
New Jersey Cream pie
New Mexico Pumpkin pie
New York Coconut custard pie
North Carolina Sweet potato pie
North Dakota Strawberry rhubarb pie
Ohio Cherry pie
Oklahoma Pecan pie
Oregon Pumpkin pie
Pennsylvania Peanut butter pie
Rhode Island Coconut custard pie
South Carolina Coconut custard pie
South Dakota Strawberry rhubarb pie
Tennessee Chess pie
Texas Pecan pie
Utah Cream pie
Vermont Cream pie
Virginia Chocolate pie
Washington Pumpkin pie
West Virginia Lemon pie
Wisconsin Strawberry rhubarb pie
Wyoming Chocolate pie

Which Thanksgiving Pies Stand Out in the Most States?

Some pies have a much wider geographic reach than others. The following table counts how many states, including Washington, D.C., have each variety as their uniquely popular pie.

Most uniquely popular pie States / district
Cherry pie 3
Chess pie 1
Chocolate pie 3
Coconut custard pie 4
Cream pie 9
French silk pie 7
Lemon pie 1
Peanut butter pie 4
Pecan pie 3
Pumpkin pie 7
Strawberry rhubarb pie 4
Sweet potato pie 5

Cream pie leads with nine states, followed by pumpkin and French silk pies at seven each. Sweet potato pie comes next with five, while chess and lemon pies each stand out in just one state.

Perhaps the biggest surprise is apple pie. Despite ranking second among pies ordered on Instacart the day before Thanksgiving, it doesn’t appear as the uniquely popular choice in any state. Its absence highlights the difference between national favorites and pies that are especially popular in particular regions.

Pumpkin Pie Rules in West; South Has Its Own Favorites

Pumpkin pie is especially popular across much of the Pacific Coast and Mountain West, including California, Oregon, Washington, and Nevada.

In the South, pecan pie is uniquely popular in Texas, Oklahoma, and Mississippi, while sweet potato pie leads in Georgia, North Carolina, Maryland, and Washington, D.C.

Both pecan and sweet potato pies have deep roots in Southern food traditions, making their regional popularity a reflection of the area’s culinary history.

French Silk Pie Is a Midwestern Favorite

French silk pie is uniquely popular across seven states, including Illinois, Iowa, Kansas, Minnesota, Missouri, and Nebraska, forming one of the clearest regional clusters on the map.

This rich chocolate pie, typically topped with whipped cream, offers an alternative to the pumpkin and fruit pies traditionally associated with Thanksgiving.

Chocolate pie also appears in Kentucky, Virginia, and Wyoming, showing that chocolate-based desserts have a place on Thanksgiving tables well beyond the Midwest.

Regional food preferences aren’t limited to Thanksgiving. A separate Visual Capitalist map of each state’s signature ice cream flavor reveals similar geographic differences, with vanilla standing out in 19 states.

Sweet Potato Pie Sees the Biggest Holiday Spike

While cream pie is uniquely popular in the most states, pumpkin pie ranks first among pies ordered on Instacart the day before Thanksgiving, followed by apple and pecan.

Sweet potato pie, however, sees the most dramatic Thanksgiving spike. On Thanksgiving Day in 2024, its share of Instacart orders was 2,691% higher than its daily average for the year, roughly 28 times its usual share.

Pumpkin and pecan pies also experienced sharp holiday increases, while apple pie orders rose more gradually throughout the fall.

Learn More on the Voronoi App

If you enjoyed today’s post, check out Mapped: Each State’s Standout Halloween Candy on Voronoi.

ALT-Lab-Ad-1

Recent Articles